Home

www.history-what-if.com 


Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy Posted on: Wed, 27 Jan 2010 20:14:35 -0500

Alfred Montestruc wrote:
> It has been mentioned that in a parliamentary democracy controversial
> legislation can be passed with a simple majority, unlike the current
> fracas in the US congress over health care legislation.

> Challenge, POD that results in the USA being formed as a parliamentary
> democracy, what happens to the USA after that?

That is quite simple, eliminate the independence of the states. You do that
by enlisting the aid of the 2nd ASB division.

The Federal government was to be a place where the narrow powers of that
uber-government were exercised. The two houses were simply a compromise on the
population differences of the states but were always to only representatives
of the states without that infernal party system that infested the British
parliament.

You will find in the beginning the states did have a single legislative
house. A separate governor simply replaced the familiar royal governor system
which was what they were familiar with. So if you want to eliminate that then
eliminate the royal governors. How you do that is up to you. Perhaps eliminate
the system of royal patronage in ancient Sumer so it never gets started.

As to copying the royal governor "he has refused toent to our laws" via
his viceroy which is the function the president/governor was supposed to
exercise rather the leader of a political party.

So rather than a system which imitated the fatherland it imitated the local
system of government imposed upon it by the fatherland.

The US did what you suggest but in a much more direct imitation than a
parliamentary system would have been.

--
It is an incredibly generous estimate to say that even one percent of
the common knowledge of the people is based upon facts in evidence.
-- The Iron Webmaster, 4220
http://www.giwersworld.org/israel/is-seg.phtml a14
Wed Jan 27 19:51:41 EST 2010
1030253. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030254. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030255. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030256. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030257. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030258. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030259. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030260. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030261. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030262. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030263. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030264. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030265. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030266. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030267. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030268. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030269. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030270. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030271. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy
1030272. Re: WI: The USA had been formed as a parliamentary democracy