Home

www.history-what-if.com 


Re: Stalin rolls the dice. Posted on: Injection- Tue, 9 Feb 2010 00:47:22 +0000 (UTC)


"a425couple" wrote in message
news:hkndmk02i65@news3.newsguy.com...
>
> "Allen W. McDonnell" wrote in ...
>> I don't buy the reflexive answer that World War III occurs instantly
>> and without hesitation, it just doesn't fit the American style based on
>> how Stalin used his weapons. IMO.
>
> Well, ok, don't buy it if you do not want to.
>
> But explain to the rest of us why you think POTUS Truman has totally
> changed (into a punching bag pacifist) from the leader that we have seen
> plenty of evidence to believe he would definitely take action.
> In WWI he served as an officer in France. (He had great feelings for the
> troops that fought, and especially those that died).
> In WWII, in one of his first decisions, he felt no doubt that the correct
> decision was to use the A bomb in order to save lives in our military. In
> early days of Korea, he decided this was worth fighting for. And now, you
> are thinking he will just say that our troops died for nothing !
> You are thinking Truman & US & UN will walk away from Korea and hand the
> world to communism !?
>

I never said Truman would just walk away, however I also don't believe he
would reflexively order total all out nuclear attack on the USSR as so many
have postulated on this thread.

I think he would have gone for a more middle of the road solution, nuke
targets in North Korea and points of entry, especially the seaports,
airports and bridges that would allow the USSR to supply more war material
to the battle field.

Maybe it would escalate into an all out attack on the USSR, but I do not see
that as a given.
--

Always appeal to a man's enlightened self interest, you can trust him to
look out for himself honestly,
It's when you appeal to his Honor or the Common Good that he stops paying
attention.

1030636. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030637. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030638. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030639. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030640. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030641. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030642. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030643. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030644. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030645. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030646. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030647. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030648. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030649. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030650. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030651. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030652. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030653. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030654. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.
1030655. Re: Stalin rolls the dice.