Home

www.history-what-if.com 


Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war? Posted on: Thu, 4 Mar 2010 17:58:35 +0100


"William Black" ha scritto nel messaggio
news:hmoi25$ns4$1@news.eternal-september.org...
>
> "Michele" wrote in message
> news:4b8fc9a9$0$1114$4fafbaef@reader4.news.tin.it...
>>
>> "William Black" ha scritto nel messaggio
>> news:hmo4qu$fst$1@news.eternal-september.org...
>>>
>>
>> You're writing this in humor, aren't you? Let me see if I can follow
>> up...
>>
>>>
>>> Traditionally French ships act in a very specific manner when facing the
>>> Royal Navy, they sink...
>>>
>>
>> Uhm, sinking... sinking... oh yes, the behavior of the HMS Sheffield when
>> facing a French-built anti-ship missile!
>
> No.
>
> That should be 'burning'.
>
> She was scuttled the next day.

Not a lot of difference there, heh. Down to the bottom it went.

>
>> And maybe that case might have some more relevance to events taking place
>> in 1985, than the glory that was Britain at Trafalgar and the courageous
>> deed at Oran, eh?
>
> Doubtful.
>
> The historical record shows that the French fleet when faced with teh
> Royal Navy, erm, sank...
>

So yes, you believe that the unfortunate case of the Sheffield, taking
place, what? two years before this hypothetical, would be less relevant than
what had happened centuries before. You _are_ joking, aren't you.

>>> Mad Maggie got blown up by the IRA in 1984 and she came marching out of
>>> the rubble, shaking the bricks out of her hair and looking for a fight.
>>
>> Well yes, but that was a nickname. You seem to be claiming that she
>> actually would say she's Napoleon on workdays and Christ on weekends...
>
> Christ!
>
> Never Christ.
>
> Her father owned a shop and didn't work with his hands...

Oh right, what about Mohammed, he traded camels, would that be OK?

I note you saw my point about embarassing sinkings in port happening even in
the best families...

1031466. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031467. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031468. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031469. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031470. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031471. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031472. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031473. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031474. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031475. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031476. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031477. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031478. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031479. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031480. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031481. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031482. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031483. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031484. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?
1031485. Re: 1985: France and New Zealand go to war?