Home

www.history-what-if.com 


Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House Posted on: Sat, 6 Mar 2010 15:12:56 +0000 (UTC)

On Mar 5, 10:56=A0pm, Alfred Montestruc wrote:
> http://www.ij.org/index.php?option=3Dcom_content&task=3Dview&id=3D1634&It=
em...

Would it really change things in the long run? Even if this case is
reversed, the pre-New Deal Court will still strike down legislation
that violate economic liberties such as freedom of contract, and the
New Deal era Courts will reverse those decisions. I may be wrong, but
I don't see much long term change with a decision the other way, it
might just be that some justices will use the Privileges and
Immunities Clause to strike down certain laws instead of the Due
Process clause.

Thanks,
Shawn
1031525. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031526. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031527. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031528. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031529. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031530. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031531. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031532. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031533. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031534. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031535. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031536. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031537. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031538. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031539. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031540. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031541. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031542. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031543. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House
1031544. Re: WI one vote changes in the US Supreme Court "Slaughter House