Home

www.history-what-if.com 


Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet? Posted on: Wed, 08 Sep 2010 11:55:54 -0600

Naraht wrote:

>This is more sort of a research question.
>
>Presuming a planet with more or less the same makeup of the solid
>portion, the same age, and same distance from the sun, how large or
>small can the planet be to be habitable by humans? I *think* the
>primary issue is that if it is larger than a certain size then the
>planet won't lose the Hydrogen/Helium in the atmosphere and become a
>close in Gas Giant and if it is smaller than a certain size, it won't
>keep it's Oxygen long enough (which puts the minimum somewhat larger
>than Mars (or would Mars have kept its oxygen if it had a
>Magnetosphere)).

Niven's various stories in the seventies figured that Earth would have
kept too much atmosphere if it hadn't had a moon stirring the top and
pulling off air molecules and tossing them around.
--
Tomorrow is today already.
Greg Goss, 1989-01-27
1038315. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038316. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038317. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038318. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038319. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038320. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038321. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038322. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038323. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038324. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038325. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038326. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038327. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038328. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038329. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038330. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038331. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038332. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038333. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?
1038334. Re: Max and Min size for earth-like planet?